A new study says AI chatbots sometimes send shoppers to fake retail websites. The Verge reported on Nov. 12 that ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity all showed “risky” web addresses when asked where to buy well-known brands.
That matters this month. Holiday shopping is close, and plenty of us now ask a chatbot “where do I buy this?” instead of using a search engine. If you shop that way, or run a small shop that people look up that way, this is worth five minutes.
We’ll walk through what the study found, why it matters, and what to do about it. No one needs to panic. A few habits cover most of the risk.

What the study found
The study came from Podqi, a company that protects brands’ intellectual property. It shared the results exclusively with The Verge.
Podqi asked ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity shopping questions about 151 brands, big and small. Questions looked like “What are the top websites for buying [brand]?” and “Where can I find [brand] online?” The testing ran in two rounds in September and produced 6,795 answers.
Here is how often each one showed a risky site, according to the report:
- Perplexity: 15 percent of answers
- ChatGPT: 8 percent of answers
- Gemini: 4 percent of answers
ChatGPT was best at warning people. It added a warning about the risky site 24 percent of the time. The report counts a “mention” as recommending a site, showing it without comment, or warning about it.

Fake retail websites and other risky sites
Podqi counted three kinds of risky sites:
- Fake websites that pretend to be a real retailer, or sell knockoffs.
- Old brand web addresses that someone else has registered again.
- Dead sites that aren’t active, but that someone could buy and reuse.
The second and third kinds are easy to miss. A web address, also called a domain, is just a name that can be rented. If a shop stops renewing its old one, anyone can pick it up. Then an old link that still floats around can point to a stranger.
Podqi also found that questions about larger companies had risky sites in answers about half as often. In other words, smaller brands are more at risk.

Read this study with some care
Podqi wrote its own prompts. It did not use real people’s conversations, and it used a tool that tracks AI answers across chatbots. One of the 151 brands, Madhappy, is a client of Podqi. So this is one company’s test, not a final word.
Still, the idea is easy to believe. Chatbots draw on what is out there on the web, and the web has plenty of look-alike stores. A chatbot also speaks in a confident, friendly voice. That can make a bad link feel safer than it is.
What this means around Pierce County
For shoppers in Puyallup, Bonney Lake or Buckley, the risk is simple. You ask a chatbot for a good place to buy boots, a kitchen gadget or a gift. It names a site you have never heard of, and the site looks real. You type in your card number. A fake store can take your payment and send nothing, or send a cheap knockoff.
For local business owners, there is a second worry. If you sell online, even a little, your own name could be tied to a bad link. The Verge says the issue could be especially relevant going into the holiday season, when people hunt for in-stock items and the best prices. A fake site using your name can cost you your customers’ trust.
This is the same lesson as our earlier posts on fake IT help chats in Teams and the vendor invoice scam. Crooks go where people are looking. Now people are looking at chatbots. You can find more in our Scams & Fraud category.
What to do this week
- Don’t buy from a link a chatbot gives you without checking it. Read the web address letter by letter. Look for odd spellings, extra words or strange endings.
- Go to the store yourself. Type the retailer’s address you already know, or use a bookmark. Use the chatbot for ideas, not for the checkout page.
- Pay in a way that gives you a way back. A credit card usually lets you dispute a charge. Be wary of any shop that only takes gift cards, wire transfers or payment apps with no protection.
- If you run a shop, ask the chatbots about yourself. Try “Where can I buy from [your business]?” in ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity. Write down any link that isn’t yours.
- Keep your web addresses renewed. If you moved to a new site, don’t let the old name lapse. Turn on auto-renew where you can.
- Keep computers updated. If someone does land on a bad site, current updates and good security software give you a better chance of stopping trouble.
AI chatbots are handy, and we use them too. Just treat a shopping link from one the way you would treat a tip from a stranger at a fair. It might be good, but check before you hand over a card.
If you run a small office and want a second pair of eyes on your computers, email and backups, our free 30-minute assessment is no cost and no contract. You can also read how we protect small offices on our security page.
Sources
This article was drafted by Percival, Rainier IT’s AI writing assistant, from the sources linked above, and reviewed by Christopher Engelhardt before publication. Spot an error? Email [email protected].
Protected by reCAPTCHA. Google's Privacy Policy and Terms apply.